Insurance Settlements

Back to the book page

To quickly search for key terms, use your browser's 'Find' function, found in the 'Edit' menu.


Table of Contents

I.  Claims Handling

 1.     How Insurance Companies Process Claims

 2.     The Claims Review Process: How to Win Claims and Influence Claims Adjusters

 3.     Aspects of Claims Frequently Questioned by Adjusters

 3A.  Spotting and Countering Adjuster “Dirty Tricks”

 4.     Managing the Client’s Expectations

II.  Valuing Claims

 5.     How Insurance Companies Value Claims

 6.     Determining and Proving Economic Damages

 7.     [Reserved]

 8.     How Reserves Are Established

8A.   Questions to Ask Insurance Experts

 9.     Proving Pain and Suffering

10.    Handling Preexisting and Subsequent Injuries

11.    Proving Hedonic Damages

12.    Using Experts in Valuing and Settling Claims

12A. Harnessing the Internet as a Claim Evaluation and Settlement Tool

12B. Using Focus Groups and Mock Trials as Tools for Personal Injury Claim Evaluation

III.  Evaluating Coverage

13.    Determining Coverage and Obtaining Policy Limits

13A. Questions to Assess Coverage Problems

14.    What to Do When Liability Is Denied

14A. Homeowner's Insurance Coverage for Mold Claims

IV.  Documenting Claims

15.    Drafting Effective Demand Letters and Settlement Brochures

16.    What Adjusters Need to Settle Claims

17.    Chiropractic Treatment in Soft Tissue Injury Cases

18.    Attorneys’ Guide to Medical Records

18A. Countering Defense Independent Medical Examinations

19.    Common Mistakes Made by Plaintiffs’ Attorneys in Documenting Claims

20.    Analyzing Opinion Letters: A Physician’s Insights on the Quality of Medical Reports

V.  Effective Negotiation

21.    Negotiating With the Insurance Adjuster

22.    Establishing Bad Faith

23.    How to Negotiate With Insurance Companies and Avoid Settlement Delays

24.    Maximizing Damages in Small Personal Injury Cases

25.    Twenty-Six Tips From Seasoned Claims Adjusters

25A. Mediation Tips for Personal Injury Counsel

VI.  Efficient Settlement

26.    Evaluating Settlement Offers

26A. Settlement Ethics

27.    Structured Settlements: Opportunities, Problems and Benefits

28.    Appraisal of Insurance Claims

29.    Solving Common Settlement Problems

29A. Handling Inflated and Other Liens

VII.  Specific Types of Cases

30.    Evaluation of Soft Tissue Injury Claims

31.    Evaluating and Settling Medical Malpractice Claims

31A. Investigating Cell Phone Use in Vehicle Liability Claim Recoveries

32.    Settling Auto Accident Cases

33.    Avoiding and Resolving the Classically Weak Case

34.    Trauma & Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD): A Brief Primer for Civil Litigation

35.    Stacking Un/Underinsured Motorist Coverages

35A. Investigating Slip and Fall Claims

36.    Investigating and Litigating Nursing Home Abuse

37.    Investigating and Evaluating the Product Liability Claim

38.    Investigating False Arrest Claims

39.    Investigating Negligent Security Claims in Pursuing Damages for Crime Victims

40.    Investigating Workplace Violence Claims

41.    Sexual Molestation Claims: Liability and Coverage Issues

42.    How to Combat Smaller and Smaller Settlement Offers in Minor Impact Soft Tissue Injury Cases

 

I.  CLAIMS HANDLING

Chapter 1: How Insurance Companies Process Claims

§100        Creation of a Claim

§101        The Reporting Process

§101.1       Reporting to the Agency Which Sold the Business

Sample: Automobile Loss Notice

Sample: General Liability Loss Notice

Sample: Property Loss Notice

§101.2       Reporting to the Carrier

Sample: Telephone Claims Report

§102        Policy and Coverage Verification

§103        Assignment for Handling

§103.1       Resolution by “Fastrack”

§103.2       Additional Information Requested by Correspondence

Sample: Statement of Claim

§103.3       Additional Investigation by Telephone or Correspondence

Sample: Schedule of Lost Contents

Sample: Claimant’s Report of Automobile Accident

§103.4       Field Investigation — Staff Adjuster or Independent Adjuster

§110        Checklist: Primary and Secondary Duties of the Adjuster

§120        Accomplishing Primary Duties

§121        Interviewing Parties Directly Involved

§121.1       Proper Identification of Interviewee

§121.2       Establishing Relationships of Parties Directly Involved

§121.3       Developing Facts From the Perspective of the Interviewee

§121.4       Determining the Specific Nature of the Injury or Property Damage

§121.5       Determining the Specific Loss Associated With the Injury or Property Damage

§121.6       Developing Any Ancillary Problems

§121.7       Conducting an Assessment of the Interviewee

§121.8       Developing Leads

§122        Confirming and Preserving Facts

§122.1       Official Records

§122.2       Inspection of Accident Site

§122.3       Inspection of Damaged Property

§122.4       Documenting Property Loss

§122.5       Assembling Medical Documents

Sample: Medical Report (Simple)

§122.6       Interviewing Witnesses

Sample: Witness Statement

§122.7       Following Up on Developed Leads

§130        Performing Secondary Duties

§131        Factors Affecting Claim Investigation

§131.1       Training

§131.2       Caseload

§131.3       Adjuster Compensation

§132        Evaluating Exposure

§133        Reserving

§133.1       Specific Methods of Reserving

§133.2       Reserve Runs

§133.3       Opening Reserve From Loss Notice

§133.4       Primary Reserves

§133.5       Reserve Review

§134        Reporting

§134.1       Informing Superiors of Details

§134.2       Recommending Reserves

Sample: Claimant Summary

§134.3       Suggesting an Action Plan

§134.4       Requesting Settlement Authority

Sample: Individual Settlement Worksheet

§135        Preparing Draft Request to Disbursal Center

§136        Salvage

§137        Subrogation and Contribution

§140        The Negotiation Process

§140.1       Settlement Conferences

§140.2       Disputed Coverage

§150        Risk and Insurance Management

§151        Risk Managers

§152        Risk Identification and Evaluation

§153        Risk Treatment

§154        Claim Handling

§160        Litigation

§170        Catastrophic Injury Claims

§171        Inside Claims Management

§171.1       Defining “Catastrophic Injury”

§171.2       Stages of Catastrophic Cases

§172        Preparing for and Responding to Catastrophic Case Issues

Chapter 2: The Claims Review Process: How to Win Claims and Influence Claims Adjusters

§200        Introduction

§201        Two Prerequisites to Closing the Claims File

§210        Providing the Necessary Documentation

§211        Documenting and Proving Liability

§212        Documenting and Proving Damages

§213        Medical References

§220        Evaluating the Claim

§221        Settlement vs. Verdict Value

§222        Kinds of Damages — Factors

§223        Is the Claim Within Normal Limits?

§230        The Adjuster’s Settlement Authority

§240        Working With Independent Claims Adjusters

Chapter 3: Aspects of Claims Frequently Questioned by Adjusters

§300        Introduction

§310        General Questions Adjusters Ask

§311        First Party Claims

§311.1       Fire Loss

§311.2       Burglary Loss

§311.3       Liability Coverage

§311.4       Uninsured Motorist Claim

§312        What Adjusters Look for in Evaluating Claims

§312.1       Causal Relationship Between the Accident, Injury, and Medical Records

§312.2       Proportionality

§312.3       Correlation Between the Medical Records and Treatment Received

§312.4       Complete Records and Supporting Documentation

§312.5       Lost Wage Documentation

§320        Red Flag Areas on Basic Claims

§320.1       First Party Casualty Losses

§320.2       First Party Property Losses

§320.3       Third Party Liability Claims

§320.4       Workers’ Compensation

§321        How Claims Adjusters Use Surveillance

§321.1       Surveillance Evidence

§321.2       Surveillance Considerations

§321.3       Flagging Cases for Surveillance

§321.4       Surveillance Options

§321.4.1    Outside Adjusters

§321.4.2    Professional Surveillance Firms

§321.4.3    Surveillance Firm Qualifications

§321.5       Preventing and Thwarting Surveillance Problems

§330        The Ramifications of Insurer Involvement in Claims

§331        Duty to Defend

§332        Reservation of Rights Letters

§321.1       Reasons for Issuing

§321.2       Two Common Concerns

§321.3       Impact on Recipient

§321.4       Responding to Reservation of Rights Letters

§333        Conflict of Interest

§334        Index Bureau

§335        Fraud

§336        Permissive Use Cases

§337        Other Insurance

§340        Contracts Affecting Liability or Responsibility

§350        Specific Categories Adjusters Watch Out for

§351        Problems Raised by Product Liability Cases

§352        Fraud

§353        Permissive Use

§354        Other Insurance

§360        Insurer Special Investigative Units (SIUs)

§361        Factors Suggesting Fraud

§361.1       Personal Factors

§361.2       Case Factors

§370        Conclusion

Chapter 3A: Spotting and Countering Adjuster “Dirty Tricks”

§300A     Introduction

§310A     State Unfair Claim Practice Laws

§320A     Insurer Motivation

§330A     Common Adjuster Ploys

§331A     “I’d like to take your statement.”

§332A     “Please sign this Medical Authorization Form.”

§333A     “Why do you need an attorney? I’ll work with you on the claim.”

§334A     “I’m here to canvass the neighborhood.”

§335A     “If you don’t accept this amount now, we will withdraw all offers.”

§336A     Colossus

§340A     Ten Tips for Complaining About Adjuster “Dirty Tricks”

§341A     Letter to Adjuster

§342A     Letter to Supervisor

§343A     Letter to Home Office

§344A     Letter to State Insurance Commissioner

Chapter 4: Managing the Client’s Expectations

§400        Types of Clients — Decision Makers and Others

§401        Paying Clients

§401.1       Hourly

§401.2       Contingency

§401.3       Flat Fee

§402        Nonpaying Decisionmakers

§402.1       Third Party Beneficiary (Insureds)

§402.2       Indigent/Pro Bono

§402.3       Institutional/Corporate

§402.4       In-House Counsel

§402.5       Insurance Companies

§402.6       Defense Counsel Duties to Insured and Insurer

§410        Entering the Battle — Clients’ Initial Expectations

§411        “The Injured” and “The Accused”

§412        Truth

§413        Justice

§414        Reality: The American Rule

§414.1       Money Damages Only (Usually)

§414.2       Pay Your Own Attorney Fees

§414.3       Protracted Battle and Delay

§420        Educating You and Your Client

§421        The Initial Contact

§422        Do I Take the Case?

§422.1       Red Flags of Danger

§422.2       Contingent Fee Agreement

§423        Writing to the New Client

§424        Gathering Information

§425        Evaluating the Case — Your Professional Opinion

§425.1       Talking About Liability

§425.2       Talking About Damages

§425.3       Further Handling

§430        Talking About Settlement

§431        The First Demand and Offer

§432        The Realistic But Hopeful Settlement Offer

§433        The Offer the Opponent Cannot Accept

§434        Continued Negotiations

§435        Talking About Negotiation Strategies

§440        Sources of Client Misinformation

§441        Popular Culture

§442        Client Relations and Communications

§442.1       Communication Techniques

§443        Failure to Respond to Inquiries

§444        Interference by Others

§445        The Multi-Million Dollar Settlement

§450        Controlling Unrealistic Expectations

§451        Can You Control Your Client?

§452        How to Get Your Client to Trust You

§453        Sources of Assistance

§454        Should You Withdraw?

§460        Responding to Complaints

§461        Your Fee in the Balance

§462        Collecting Unpaid Fees

§470    Managing the “Difficult” Client

§471    Introduction

§472    Factors Making Clients Difficult

§472.1     Naiveté About the Court and Tort System

§472.2     Grandiose Expectations of Financial Recovery

§472.3     They Feel Bad

§472.4     They Face Financial Pressures

§472.5     Misplaced Expectations for Retribution or Vindication

§472.6     You Have Many Cases — They Have One

§472.7     Distrust of Lawyers

§472.8     “Peanut Gallery” Advice

§473    Practical Hints for Spotting and Avoiding the Difficult Client

§473.1     Telltale Danger Signs

§473.2     Trust Your Gut

§474    Whether to Disengage

§475    Disengagement Techniques

§476    Client Control Issues in Managing Difficult Clients

§477    Adversaries Have Client Control Issues

§478    Conclusion

II.  VALUING CLAIMS

Chapter 5: How Insurance Companies Value Claims

§500        Overview

§501        Introduction

§510        Claim Organizations — Insurance Carriers and Others

§510.1       Anatomy of a Claim Department

§510.2       Claim Department Organization 

§510.3       Role of Caseloads in Adjuster Evaluations

§510.4       Role of Claim Valuation Software

§511        Insurance Company Classifications

§511.1       Commercial Carriers

§511.2       Personal Lines Carriers

§512        Organizations Retaining Claims Exposure

§512.1       Self Insureds

§512.2       Self-Insured, Self-Administered Entities

§512.3       Uninsured Defendants

§513        Noncarrier Claim Organizations

§513.1       Third Party Administrators (TPAs)

§513.2       Independent Insurance Adjusters

§514        Summary

§520        Flexibility in Settlement Evaluations

§521        Settlement Ranges

§522        Effect of Plaintiff’s Demand

§522.1       Effect of Policy Limits Demand

§530        Economic Factors Affecting Case Evaluation

§531        Medical and Related Expenses

§532        Loss of Earnings and Earning Capacity

§533        Defense Costs

§540        Noneconomic Factors Affecting Case Evaluation

§541        Estimates of Liability

§541.1       Probability of Liability

§541.2       Comparative Negligence

§541.3       Contributions and Other Factors

§541.4       Claim Committees

§542        Insurance Matters

§542.1       Insured’s Attitude and Control

§542.2       Amount of Insurance

§542.3       Excess Carrier Involvement

§542.4       Coverage Disputes

§542.5       Insurance Policy Provisions Regarding Valuation of Claims

§543        Effect of Elaborate Settlement Proposals

§544        Jurisdiction

§545        Codefendant Factors

§545.1       Opportunity for Indemnity

§545.2       Self-Insured or Uninsured Codefendant

§546        Threats of Bad Faith

§547        Horror Factor

§548        Plaintiff Attorney Experience and Reputation

§549        Reference to Jury Verdict Reports

§550        Common Evaluation Techniques

§551        The X Times Specials Formula

§552        [Reserved]

§553        Earnings as Index to Special Damages

§554        Judgment/Experience Method

§555        Scheduled Evaluation Methods

§555.1       Unit of Disability Method

§555.2       Hourly Unit of Time

§556        Computer/Statistical Methods

§560        Case Evaluation Examples Based Upon Case Severity

§560.1       Assigning Unit Values

§560.2       Evaluation of Permanent Disability

§561        Minor Injury Cases

§562        Significant Injury Cases

§563        Catastrophic Injury Cases

§563.1       Loss of Earnings and Earning Capacity

§563.2       Future Medical Care

§563.3       Wrongful Death Claims

§570        Alternate Resolution Methods

§571        Pretrial Settlement Conferences

§572        Arbitration, Mock Trial, etc.

§573        Mary Carter Agreements

§574        Separate Settlements

§575        Structured Settlements

§580        Adjuster Evaluation Ploys & Other Insider Info

§581        Evaluation Ploys

§582        Ten Methods to “Unfreeze Adjuster” Case Evaluations

§583        Confessions of a Claims Adjuster

§584        Common Insurance Claim Evaluation Myths

Chapter 6: Determining and Proving Economic Damages

§600        Elements of Economic Damages

§601        Loss of Income Production

§602        Loss of Economic Opportunity

§602.1       Labor Shortages in the 21st Century

§603        Loss of Labor and Skills to Family

§604        Loss of Postinjury Worklife Income and Estate Value

§604.1       Changes in Social Security Retirement Age

§605        Loss of Personal/Family/Social Relationships

§605.1       Hedonic Damages

§606        Losses and Expenses Related to Vocational Rehabilitation

§606.1       Order of Selection

§610        Documenting Economic Damages

§611        Defining Postinjury Capability

§612        Defining Residual Functional Capacity

§612.1       AMA Permanent Impairment Rating

§612.2       Evaluating Work Tolerance

§612.3       Job Search and ADA

§613        Defining Transferable Skills and Capacities

§613.1       Standard Vocational Assessment Techniques

§620        Proving Loss of Past Wages and Future Economic Opportunity

§621        Defining Preinjury Income Stream and Career Development Potential

§622        Defining Individual Postinjury Career Development and Income Potential

§623        Defining Postinjury Career Development and Income Potential With Generic Data

§624        Estimating Length of Worklife

§630        Death or Disablement of Unemployed Persons

§631        Employers and the Disabled

§632        Documenting Good Faith Job Search

§632.1       Faulty Application Forms

§640        Defining Contribution of Labor and Skills to Family

§641        Fair Market Value of Household and Personal Services

§650        Loss of Post-Worklife Income and Estate Value

§651        Reduced Pension and Social Security Income

§652        Reduced Savings and Property Holdings

§660        Adjustment to Changes in Lifestyle Caused by Economic Damages and Restriction of Opportunities

§661        Independence and Avocational Pursuits

§661.1       ADA and Public Access

§662        Self-Concept and Self-Esteem

§662.1       Worst-Case Scenario

§663        Career Development and Stagnation

§670        Vocational Rehabilitation Intervention

§671        Establishing Plaintiff Feasibility for Rehabilitation Intervention

§672        Vocational Rehabilitation Services

§673        Rehabilitant Profile

§674        The Rehabilitation Counselor as a Vocational and Present Value Expert Witness

§674.1       Rehabilitation Economists

§675        Assessments for Evaluating Economic Damages

§676        Present Value Computation

Sample: Present Value Computation

§677        Economic Impact of Vocational Rehabilitation

Sample: Table Showing Economic Impact With Vocational Rehabilitation

§678        Economic Impact of No Vocational Rehabilitation

Sample: Table Showing Economic Impact Without Vocational Rehabilitation

§680        Intangible Variables Which Affect Evaluation of Damages

§681        Defining Individual Differences

§682        The Agony of Litigation

§690        Defining Objective Measures of Damages

Chapter 7 [Reserved]

Chapter 8: How Reserves Are Established

§800        In General

§801        What Are Reserves?

§802        Financial Implications of Reserving

§803        Reserves and Settlement

§810        How Reserves Are Established

§811        Elements of Consideration When Setting Reserves

§812        Sample Case Evaluation

§813        Reserve Guidelines

§820        Specific Methods of Reserving

§821        Average Value Method

§822        Loss Ratio Method

§823        Tabular Value Method

§824        “Reserved to Exposure”

§825        Reserve Review

§830        How Reserves Are Used

§831        Importance of Reserves to Adjusters

§832        Adjusting Reserves

§833        Summary of Factors Contributing to a Claim Evaluation

§840        Example of Case Reserving

§850        Conclusion

Chapter 8A: Questions to Ask Insurance Experts

§800A     Introduction

§810A     Checklist — Questions for Insurance Experts

§820A     Resources for Finding Insurance Experts

Chapter 9: Proving Pain and Suffering

§900        Introduction/Sources of Proof

§910        Investigating and Preparing Your Case

§920        Negotiating (Trying) Your Case to the Insurance Company

§930        Settlement Practice Tips and Tactics

§940        Litigation — Trying the Case to a Jury

§950        Checklist: The Ten Commandments of Proving Pain and Suffering

Chapter 10: Handling Preexisting and Subsequent Injuries

§1000      Overview

§1010      Preliminary Investigation

§1011      Query the Client

§1011.1     Importance of Honesty

§1012      Preexisting Injury or Preexisting Condition

§1012.1     Medical Records

§1013      Investigate Prior Injuries

§1013.1     Medical Textbooks

§1014      Investigate Prior Diseases

§1015      Investigate Subsequent Injuries

§1020      Effective Use of the Treating Physician

§1021      The Role of the Treating Physician

§1022      Query the Physician

§1023      Physician’s Medical Report

Sample: Physician’s Report

§1024      Physician’s Deposition

§1030      Proximate Cause

§1031      Differentiate Old Injuries From New Injuries

§1031.1     Subsequent Injuries

§1031.2     Subsequent Medical Negligence

§1032      Actions of the Defendant

§1033      Types of Causation

§1034      Prepare the Doctor for Proximate Cause

§1035      Potential Cross-Examination of Plaintiff

§1040      Damages

§1041      Medical Expenses

§1041.1     Future Medical Expenses

§1042      Disability and Disfigurement

§1043      Pain and Suffering

§1044      Loss of Earnings

§1045      Aggravation of Preexisting Conditions

§1046      Loss of Consortium

§1047      Loss of Enjoyment of Life

§1048      Mitigation of Damages

§1049      Apportionment of Damages

§1050      Negotiation Strategies

§1051      Analyze the Evidence

Chapter 11: Proving Hedonic Damages

§1100      Hedonic Damages

§1101      Development of the Concept

§1102      Variation Among State Statutes

§1110      Categories of Personal Injury Damages

§1120      The Landmark Case of Sherrod v. Berry

§1121      District Court Opinion

§1122      Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals Affirmation

§1123      Seventh Circuit Court En Banc Rehearing

§1130      Loss of Enjoyment of Life

§1131      Supporting Case Law

§1140      Cost-Benefit Analysis

§1141      Establishing the Value of Human Life

§1150      Loss of Enjoyment of Life vs. Pain and Suffering

§1151      Proving Loss of Enjoyment of Life

§1160      Using an Economist to Determine Value of Life Estimates

Sample: Direct Examination of Economist

Sample: Cross-Examination of Economist

§1161      Using Lay Witnesses to Supplement Economist’s Testimony

Table: Hedonic Damages in Personal Injury Cases

Chapter 12: Using Experts In Valuing and Settling Claims

§1200      Introduction

§1201      Overview

§1202      Deciding Whether to Use an Expert

§1203      Facts and Information Upon Which Experts Rely

§1204      Determining Whether an Expert Should Testify

§1205      Styles of Expert Testimony

§1210      Experts as Consultants

§1220      Selecting Experts

§1221      Introduction

§1222      Referrals From Counsel

§1223      The Professional Witness

§1224      Contacting and Communicating With Expert Witnesses

§1225      Checklist — Finding, Screening, and Using Experts

§1226      Expert Retention Letter

§1227      Selecting the Right Life Care Planner for Your Personal Injury Case

                §1227.1   What Is a Life Care Planner

                §1227.2   When a Life Care Planner Is Needed

                §1227.3   Case Selection Checklist

                §1227.4   Role of Life Care Planner

                §1227.5   Cost

                §1227.6   References

                §1227.7   Current Case Load

                §1227.8   Professional Credentials, Background and Training

                §1227.9   Life Care Planner Selection Checklist

                §1227.10 Red Flags

                §1227.11 Conclusion

                §1227.12 Resources

§1230      Discovery of Expert Opinions

§1231      Statutory Disclosure Requirements

§1232      Expert Testimony

§1233      Federal Rules of Evidence, Rules 702, 703, and 705

§1234      Cross-Examining an Opponent’s Expert

§1240      Limitations on the Use of Experts

§1241      Frye v. United States

§1242      Daubert v. Merrell-Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc.

§1243      The Lesson of Ofstedahl v. City of Phoenix

§1250      Ethical Considerations

§1260      Expert Fees

Chapter 12A: Harnessing the Internet as a Claim Evaluation and Settlement Tool

§1200A   Introduction

§1210A   On-Line Requirements

§1220A   Internet Resources

§1221A   Search Engines

§1222A   Legal Research Databases

§1223A   Forums and Listserves

§1224A   Web Sites and Home Pages

§1225A   Court Forms on the Internet

§1230A   Specific Uses for the Internet as a Claim Evaluation and Settlement Tool

§1231A   Litigation Management and Support

§1232A   Networking

§1233A   Information Gathering

§1234A   Researching Expert Witnesses

§1234A.1  Identifying and Retaining Expert Witnesses

§1234A.2  Neutralizing Hostile Experts

§1235A   Evaluating and Mediating Claims Online

§1240A   Speed Bumps on the Information Superhighway

§1241A   Security Issues

§1242A   Timeliness Concerns

§1243A   Computer Viruses

§1244A   The “Spam” Factor

§1245A   Defamation Risks

Chapter 12B: Using Focus Groups and Mock Trials as Tools in Personal Injury Claim Evaluation

§1200B           Introduction

§1210B           The Difference Between Focus Groups and Mock Trials

§1211B   In General

§1212B   Focus Groups

§1213B   Mock Trials

§1214B   Sequential Use

§1220B           Advantages of Focus Groups and Mock Trials        

§1221B   Force Advance Preparation

§1222B   Give Each Side Advance Peek at Other’s Arguments

§1223B   Preview Juror Reactions

§1224B   Provide Opportunity to Test and Fine-Tune Arguments and Themes

§1225B   Provide Opportunity to Test Efficacy of Evidence

§1226B   Provide Objective Valuation

§1227B   Calibrate Client Expectations

§1228B   Let Client See You Work

§1230B           Disadvantages of Focus Groups and Mock Trials

§1231B   Cost

§1232B   Feedback May Be Unreliable

§1233B   Inability to Strike Mock Jurors

§1234B   Inability to Duplicate Sympathy Factor

§1235B   Time Constraints

§1236B   Other Difficulties With Mock Trials

§1240B           Respective Roles of Vendor and Counsel in Mock Trials and Focus Groups

§1241B   Counsel’s Role

§1242B   Vendor’s Role

§1250B           Tips for Doing it Right

§1251B   Whether to Recommend a Mock Trial or Focus Group

§1252B   Use Demonstrative Evidence

§1253B   Other Tips for Mock Trials

§1260B           Caveats

§1261B   Small Venues

§1262B   Use of Results in Mediation

§1263B   Confidentiality

§1270B           Selecting the Vendor

§1271B   Finding the Right Vendor

§1272B   Selected Vendors for Mock Trials and Focus Groups

III.  EVALUATING COVERAGE

Chapter 13: Determining Coverage and Obtaining Policy Limits

§1300      Establishing Coverage

§1301      Discover Existing Policies

§1301.1     Lost Policies

§1302      Intentional Torts

§1302.1     Is Defendant Covered?

§1302.2     Avoiding the “Intentional” Exclusion

§1302.3     “Intentional” or “Wrongful” Conduct?

§1302.4     Intended Conduct that Is “Negligent”

§1303      Continuing Occurrences and Progressive Injuries

§1303.1     Multiple Insurance Policies

§1303.2     Trigger Issue — Identifying Implicated Policies

§1303.3     Manifestation Theory’s Impact on Coverage

§1303.4     Emerging Trend Toward Adoption of Multiple Trigger Theories

§1303.5     Allocation of Costs Among Insurers

§1303.6     Number of Occurrences in Multiple Injury Cases

§1304      Excess Insurance

§1305      Know When Not to Demand Policy Limits

§1306      Don’t Demand Policy Limits Unconditionally if Damages Exceed Minimal Limits

§1307      Documenting the Assets of the Defendant

§1308      Communicate With Your Client and Obtain Consent to Settle

§1309      Review Underinsured Motorist Coverage

§1310      Obtaining the Tortfeasor’s Policy Limits

§1311      Checklist for Settlement Demand

§1312      Meeting With Adjuster

§1313      Using Client’s Uninsured Motorist Policy When Coverage Is Excluded Under the Tortfeasor’s Liability Policy as an “Intentional Act”

§1320      Persuading the Insurance Carrier to Reveal Policy Limits

§1321      Reasons Why Insurance Carriers Don’t Usually Reveal Policy Limits

§1322      Devices for Persuading Adjusters to Reveal Policy Limits

§1330      Coercing Stubborn Insurance Companies to Pay Policy Limits

§1331      Law Regarding “Bad Faith” Actions

§1331.1     Insurer’s Duty of Good Faith

§1331.2     Essential Prerequisites for Recovery of Bad Faith Damages

§1331.3     Insurer’s Liability Above Coverage Limit

§1331.4     Examples of Bad Faith

§1331.5     “Bad Faith” in Denying that the Tortfeasor Is Uninsured

§1332      Defense Counsel’s Perspective in Preventing Bad Faith Exposure

§1333      Coercive Devices for Obtaining Policy Limits

§1334      Breaking the Stalemate With an Insurance Adjuster

§1335      Combining Approaches

§1336      Breaking the Stalemate With a Defense Attorney

§1340      Coercing the Stubborn Underinsured Motorist Carrier to Approve a Policy Limits Settlement

§1350      Policy Limits and Structured Settlements

§1360      Checklist — Avoiding Malpractice Relating to Acceptance of Policy Limits

§1370      The Carrier’s Duty to Provide Independent Counsel

§1371      Conflicts of Interest Requiring Independent Counsel

§1372      Types of Conflicts Requiring Independent Counsel

§1373      When Independent Counsel Not Required

§1374      Duties of Independent Counsel

§1375      Selection of Independent Counsel

§1376      Payment of Independent Counsel

§1377      Privileged Communications in Conflict of Interest Cases

§1378      Duties of Counsel Selected by Insurer Where There Is a Conflict of Interest

§1379      Duties of Counsel Selected by Insurer Where There Is no Conflict of Interest

§1380      Duties of Coverage Counsel

§1381      Control of Litigation

§1382      Insurer’s Reservation of Rights as to Reimbursement and Independent Counsel Issues

§1383      Obtaining Recovery of Pretender Fees

§1384      Duty to Defend Only Suits

§1390      Duties Between Independent Counsel and Insurer-Selected Counsel

Chapter 13A: Questions to Assess Coverage Problems

§1300A   Introduction

§1310A   Common Coverage Defenses

§1320A   Insurer Ploys

§1330A   Dynamic Nature of Coverage Issues

§1340A   Avoid Malpractice Claims

§1350A   Checklist — Questions to Assess Coverage Problems

§1360A   Sample Reservation of Rights Letter

§1370A   Sample Non-Waiver Agreement

Chapter 14: What to Do When Liability Is Denied

§1400      Introduction

§1410      Determining Why the Claim Was Denied

§1411      Information Required From the Client

§1412      Contacting the Agent

§1413      Writing the Insurance Company To Obtain Information

§1420      Assessing the Potential Claim

§1421      Breach of Contract

Checklist: Elements of Breach of Contract

§1422      Bad Faith

Checklist: Elements of Bad Faith

§1423      Fraud

§1424      Negligence

§1425      Unfair Business Practices

§1430      Pre-Suit Investigation

§1431      Insurance Department Records

§1432      Government and Court Records

§1440      Discovery

§1441      Interrogatories

§1441.1     Contentions

§1442      Request for Production and Subpoena of Insurance Files and Documents

§1442.1     The Internal Claims File

§1442.2     Agent’s File

§1442.3     Underwriting File

§1442.4     Training and Marketing Materials

§1442.5     Bonus Programs

§1442.6     Complaint Records

§1443      Depositions

§1443.1     Agent

§1443.2     Claims Personnel

§1443.3     “No-Lose” Questions

§1443.4     Deposition Outline — Defense Medical Expert

§1443.5     Examination Techniques — Defense Medical Expert

§1450      Trial Strategy

§1451      Voir Dire

§1451.1 Checklist — Voir Dire

§1451.2 Examination Techniques

§1452      Opening Statement

§1453      Order of Witnesses

§1454      Closing Argument

Chapter 14A: Homeowner's Insurance Coverage for Mold Claims

§1400A   Introduction

§1410A   How Mold Problems Arise

§1420A   Why Are Mold Claims So Prevalent Now?

§1430A   The Ballard Case

§1440A   Extent of Problem

§1450A   Possible Causes of Action and Defendants

§1451A   First Party Claims